Lenoxville General Store Hoagie Sauce (Italian Sandwich Dressing

Total Time
Prep 5 mins
Cook 0 mins

This was a secret recipe from a deli in North Eastern PA that was doused on all the hoagies (submarine sandwiches) we sold. You might want to scale this recipe for home use!

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. mix all ingredients together in a large jar.
Most Helpful

I scaled it down to make 1 cup, and made it in my Good Seasons cruet.. the flavor is best when made a day in advance.. this is a delicious dressing for Italian subs! I highly recommend it, and will use it again.

steve in FL August 18, 2009

I quartered this recipe and still had too much for a large family gathering. Also, it needs something to keep it from separating.

shaelatoo June 29, 2009