This was awesome. So glad this was posted! Never would have thought of it! I made some changes based on reviews. We made 4 steaks so I doubled the butter, but kept the mayo the same. Used only 2 T lemon juice, 2 t Worcestershire sauce, 1/2 t seasoned salt, couple dashes of paprika, 1/4 tsp basil and dill (dried) and some garlic powder. I threw some sliced mushrooms in there too. This was so so good. And you are right! The mayo is the trick! If you think its too heavy in mayo flavor as written then just lessen it up. Everyone in my family loved this! Will absolutely make again!
I only made one piece of salmon so I cut everything in half. Husband loved it!
Score another winner for Kittencal! This was delicious. I thought I had plenty of mayo, but as usual the boys left the jar nearly empty. So, I used a little mayo and some homemade plain yogurt. The recipe was very tasty and made a big hit with the gang.
Kittencal, you never cease to amaze me. This was such a delicious meal, made this for one steak and baked it a bit longer since ours was pretty thick. Can't wait to make this again; thanks!
Very good and great with rice. Relatively quick and simple for a busy bee!
No star rating as I didn't make this quite according to directions. I halvedthe recipe and eyeballed the amounts. I added a teaspoon of soy sauce, and subbed olive oil for butter (I was out). I added sliced mushrooms to the sauce. This tasted okay, but was definately not my favorite preparation. The mayo and lemon were the strongest flavors in this.
WOW!! This is amazing! I eyeballed all the ingredients, and did not have any lemon juice. Also, I used smoked paprika, and lots of it. This came together in no time at all, and was so good. Next time I will add some garlic.
Excellent!! I used a salmon filet because that is what I had, it still came out beautifully. So quick and easy. This is a keeper. I have made this many times since my first review and it is becoming my favorite. I give my husband a choice and he always chooses this one. Thanks Kittencal for such a great recipe. I always use your recipe first if I have a choice.
We love this recipe. Delicious flavor and SO easy!