Total Time
Prep 5 mins
Cook 17 mins

Perfect for Father's Day, I can't believe this simple, yet oh so tasty recipe is not already here! Do NOT cook longer than medium, my Mom likes her steak well-done! (No wonder she says she doesn't like steak, it has been reduced to shoe leather! LOL) Time does not include marinading time. Adapted from Fine Cooking - Issue 33.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. In a bowl, combine the first six ingredients and rub both sides of the steak with equal amounts of the mixture.
  2. Let marinade for 1 to 2 hours.
  3. Set aside and prepare the grill to medium hot (you'll be able to hold your hand just above the grate for 2 seconds).
  4. Drain liquid from the steak and rub both sides of the steak with salt.
  5. Grill the steak on one side for 7 to 10 minutes, keeping the smaller tenderloin section over a less intense heat.
  6. If there are flare-ups, move the steak to another part of the grill that is cooler.
  7. Turn the steak and grill for another 6 to 7 minutes. It should be rare to medium rare at this point.
  8. Medium is about 10 minutes per side.
  9. Transfer the steak to a wooden carving platter and let it rest for 3 to 4 minutes so the meat relaxes and the juices redistribute.
  10. Serve it whole or else carve it, slice it, and reassemble it, saving the juices to pour over it.
  11. Fight over who gets which piece of the steak. LOL.
Most Helpful

We used rib eye steaks. I used a bit less of pepper. I used the rosemary and it gave a great taste to the steaks. Next time I'll add chopped garlic to give more flavor. Thanks Scoutie :) Made for 123 hit wonders

Boomette August 23, 2010

Delicious steak!!! I made this using one large bone-in rib eye steak and then reduced the other ingredients by half. The only change I made was to leave out the rosemary as I don't care for it. I drained the shallots and put them in heavy duty foil, dotted with butter and some seasoned salt, and grilled these along with the steak. Thanks so much for sharing the recipe. Made for Holiday Tag Game.

diner524 July 07, 2010

This was a lovely marinade for steak. I used boneless club steaks, which came out very flavorful. Make sure you really rub in the salt, as that is what really brings out all the wonderful flavors. My fresh rosemary from the garden gave just the right touch! Thanks for sharing this.

JackieOhNo! August 30, 2010