Total Time
Prep 8 mins
Cook 10 mins

My grandpa made this for us when we would stay all night. I watched him from start to finish and this is what I came up with.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. On the stovetop, turn on to medium heat and use a griddle.
  2. In a bowl big enough to dunk your bread, add the 3 egg yolks and 1 whole egg and 1/4 cup of milk and with a fork, stir these ingredients.
  3. Add the vanilla and cinnamon.
  4. When the griddle gets warm, quickly, put in your slices of bread in the mixture, both sides.
  5. If you let it soak, the bread will fall apart.
  6. Wait until the bread is a golden brown and flip to cook the other side.
  7. Serve with butter and maple sryup or for a little less fat, sprinkle with powered sugar and add some strawberries.
  8. I have cooked this alot in my life, and after trial and error, I have decided that if you add 4 whole eggs, you are just cooking eggs on a slice of bread, but you need something to keep everything together, so you need a little something like the egg whites to do that.
  9. See what you think.
Most Helpful

4 5

Very good, but we thought it had too much cinnamon in it. Still really tasty tho!

5 5

Very yummy! I think this is much better, only using the one whole egg with 3 yolks, because this makes the toast less "eggy" tasting. Was great with country style maple syrup.

5 5

French toast for me has always been an eyeball-it type recipe, and I always did it that way since I learned the basics when I was younger, so this is the first actual french toast recipe I've used before. I made a few changes; sliced french bread toasted, Eggbeaters (3/4 cup to equal 3 eggs), and soy milk for regular milk. I do not tolerate real milk or egg yolks well at all due to IBS. I also added a couple sprinkles of nutmeg, but kept the amounts of the cinnamon and vanilla extract the same. Turned out very nicely, and I liked toasting the bread first. Bread was still soft inside and slightly crispy outside w/o being totally mushy inside. The taste was perfect and my bf also thought this was great. 6 1/2 inch thick slices worked well for the amount of egg mixture. I flipped the slices over and over in the mix to get enough of the flavor. I used our griddle at 350 degrees. Thank you Jennifer Lewis & your grandpa for a super simple, tasty french toast recipe.