Dreamer - I don't know if I did something wrong but these treats did not set up for me. I was able to save a dozen treats for Libby but the rest just crumbled after baking. The treats I could save are still very soft even after cooling an hour so I'm concerned they are just going to break up too. It all is good as I just took the crumbles and sprinkled them into her dog bowl for breakfast and she is very happy...so for doggy treat taste 5 stars but for making into treats I'm going to leave this unrated until I have a chance to try them again. Made for Photo Tag.