Prep 10 mins
Cook 1 hr 30 mins
Garlic & Horseradish...what could be better?! I got this recipe form Central Market located here in TX and changed it a bit. (Cook time is actually the time to let it marinate in the fridge)
- 118.29 ml prepared non-creamy horseradish
- 59.14 ml creole mustard or 59.14 ml any spicy mustard
- 10-12 clove garlic, peeled,finely chopped
- 29.58 ml olive oil
- 29.58 ml cracked black pepper
- 2-4 New York strip steaks or 2-4 rib eye steaks or 2-4 porterhouse steaks (this is also great using a roast)
- kosher salt or sea salt
- cracked black pepper
- Whisk the horseradish, mustard, garlic, olive oil and 2 tablespoons pepper in a bowl.
- Spread generously over the beef.
- Marinate, covered, in the refrigerator for 1 to 2 hours.
- Season with kosher salt and additional pepper.
- Grill or broil to desired temperature.
- Note: It is best never to pierce a steak with a fork when turning as you will lose some of the juices and cause the steak to be less tender.
- Also, when grilling, may I suggest grilling an onion at the same time (This trick taught to me by Titanium Chef, her recipe#25572).
- Note: To avoid the crust from falling off while grilling I suggest using a flat grill pan (the type with the holes in it). Be sure to spray it with a non-stick spray and let it heat before placing the steak on it.
I used a sirloin and had great results. I was a little leary of so much horseradish but never fear, it has a great flavor with all the garlic and pepper. The only problem I had was keeping the crust on so I put it on the George Foreman and WOW! Great recipe Risë!
Risë, this was unbelievable. Reading that other people had problems with the crust falling off, we made a foil boat for the steaks and did them on the grill with some hickory chips. We loved the steaks done this way and this is a keeper for us. Thanks for posting!
I too used top sirloin..it was on sale this week. I ended up marinading for more like 4 hours and what a tender tasty steak. I love garlic so I probably ended up putting in a little bit more, but otherwise followed the recipe. Thanks for a great idea!