When I think of 'fudgy' I don't think of these... they weren't very chocolatey or sweet. They were dry and did not keep well. Basically the muffin part was tasteless, I could only taste the peanut butter.
I saw this recipe the day it was posted and thought it sounded interesting. I finally tried it today and found the muffins to be quite good. I wouldn't call them fudgy, but they were tasty nonetheless. A good, quick recipe that uses things always on hand. Thanks for posting!