- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
I love fluffernutters! I used smooth peanut butter and the marshmallow fluff and PB creamed together so well. Great sandwich, thanks a lot.
Classic! I ate these all the time when I was younger. I remember making them like it was y'day. Thanks for the recipe! And we did call them Fluffer Nutters here in FL. :)
You've gotta grill these like grilled cheese sandwiches! It's the best!! :)
We love these. Brings back great memories. Don't tell anyone, but I still enjoy these from time to time as an adult :-)
my kids took one bite.. gagged and said NO THANK YOU.. they all hated it. ALL 7 of my kids hated it. rather sad. sorry..
This has become my son's favorite lunchbox treat. Thanks for posting!
Love this sandwich! But, I prefer the bread toasted.
YUMMY! I've always done them a bit differently. I mix the fluff and PB together in a bowl first (which makes it less messy to spread). I also add honey to the mix, and toast the bread a bit.
It was so fun to see this recipe in writing! It's a favorite in our house. When we moved to Virginia, people thought we were crazy but my sons' friends all eat them now! Thanks for the memories... Tracey