Actually 4.5 only because it didn't set up properly. I followed directions (gasp!), too. But, OMG HOW DELICIOUS!!! Which is why I rounded UP the stars instead of down. ;) This is so silky smooth & luscious. Absolutely divine! I can see making this daily with a different fruit each time. Well, maybe not EVERY single day, but you know what I mean. Next time I will use 2 packets of gelatin. Made for ZWT9, Mike & the Appliance Killers!