8 Reviews

I liked this, but it was a little too gelatonous in texture for me. I used cool whip (as one of the reviewers suggested) instead of whipped cream - I wasn't sure how much 1c of whipped cream makes, but I probably added 2.5 cups? I thought the flavor was very good - I used Gingerbread flavor eggnog because that is what I had. I also bought a graham cracker crust because I thought it went with this pie more than pastry crust. I also used 1 tps of rum because I didn't have rum extract. If I made it again, I think I would use pudding (vanilla?) instead of gelatin and use the eggnog instead of milk in the pie - that might give it a more creamy texture.

1 person found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
WorkingMom2three January 23, 2008

This was amazing and the first pie gone at a large Thanksgiving dinner. My husband requested I make another the day after.

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Sadieveggirl November 24, 2012

This is the second year in a row I've made this pie. Now I only need to remember to make it more often! I made it using the leftover eggnog from the holidays that no one drank, and it always is a big winner. I made a gingerbread crust that I blind baked to pour the filling into. Turned out great. Thanks for a great dessert!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Sarah_Star January 03, 2009

Awesome dessert! My family loves it! Tried it the first time with Whipping Cream, didn't care for the texture but tasted great! Made it again last night and used Cool Whip, AWESOME texture and taste! Going to make it for Thanksgiving!! Thank you Kittencal for the great recipes you submit!!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Babydoll318 October 20, 2007

Fabulous! Added 1 tsp of nutmeg Instead of rum extract, I added 2 tbs of rum while the eggnog mixture was still being heated. Everyone raved about it.

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Hoju's Mama December 28, 2006

Creamy, fluffy, and light-textured pie. I used Promised Land eggnog which is very rich but which doesn't have as strong an "eggnog" flavor as other brands. Horizon organic lowfat eggnog is my favorite for flavor, but it's hard to find, and I think would have been a better choice for my preference. Easy and foolproof recipe, and so nice to be able to make dessert the night before. Served this for Christmas dinner and really enjoyed it with coffee for dessert. Someone who doesn't have time to make crust could use a shortbread or graham crust and still have a wonderful dessert. Thanks for sharing the recipe!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
LonghornMama December 25, 2006

This is a great eggnog pie! I made it for Christmas Eve dinner and it turned out perfect. I even used fat-free cool whip instead of the whipping cream and it was still very rich. I love how easy it was to make as well - it was done in no time. This will definitely be on the list for future Christmas treats. I also posted a picture. Thanks for a great recipe!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Chris from Kansas December 24, 2004

It was very good and something different! For a firm, custard-like texture, I would refrigerate this pie longer than 3 hours. I served this not long after the 3 hour chilling period and found that the pie tended to run together when slicing. I refrigerated leftovers until today and re-served it to another bunch; much easier to cut/more firm. I received many compliments; thanks for posting this one, Kittencal!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
TheDancingCook December 25, 2003
Fantastic Creamy Eggnog Pie