We love this. I doubled the recipe and still have one pie in the freezer. I used a gram cracker crust and it was very nice. A flavor all its own, but you would almost think there was chocolate in it. This was also great cold the next day and held up very well for the week we had it in the fridge as we ate two small pieces each night.
I love elderberries... i just made the pie and it is beautiful and delicious... i used the urbanmam recipe for pie crust, and followed the link from his blog to your recipe and it is wonderful, thank you
Wonderful!!! We picked (on June Mountain) and cleaned (which takes a long time because they are so little) the berries one afternoon and made the pie the next day, using a pre-made pie crust because I stink at making good pie crust. It was delicious. Reading the reviews below, I can't imagine that MartinMama used this recipe and had it come out not good. Makes me think that maybe your berries were not fully ripe. If they don't have that coated (powdered sugar) look on them - they aren't ready. Thanks for this sharing this recipe, Roger/OH - it's a winner!
Not only has this recipe become a staple in our holidays each year, but as we pick a ton of elderberries each year, I also used it as a basis for my jam recipe.
We loved it so much, we're spreading the word! We shot a video on baking tips and added a homemade crust recipe that works really well with it.
Very good pie. Nice consistency to the pie. I added more lemon juice after tasting filling, just my preference. Thank you for a great recipe.
I was thoroughly disappointed with this recipe, seeing how it has such high scores. I fixed it this year for thanksgiving(09) and it was so gross! Grant it, I have never made an elderberry pie before, but have made many many other pies. People said about this pie: "It isn't sweet enough", "why is it crunchy", "eww, gross". I will not be making an elderberry pie, again. I'll save them for jelly and for a cold and flu tonic.
Before reading this recipe I never thought those berries near our home were edible. It was very simple to follow and the result was a pie that the family ate up in minutes.
I made this pie and shared some of it with my mother. She just called to say it was the most wonderful Elderberry Pie she had ever tasted! I had to find the recipe again to print a copy out for her! Thank you so much for getting this recipe from your Dad.
My wife and I were unsure, as we read that eating raw elderberries can make you very sick. There are many plants growing around the corner from our house and we picked them, followed the recipe, and it was terrific. My whole family ate it for dessert and the feeling that we picked them ourselves was just great. We used a frozen pie crust. Perfect. You need a top, so we bought two and cut the other one apart to lay on top. It wasn't pretty, but MMmmm... Thanks!
Love it, I'm from Ohio too and my mom made this when I was growing up many years ago.