- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
This recipe was so easy, and smelled great when baking. My kids ate the first batch before they even made it to the cookie jar!
Very nice, subtle flavour. Smelled wonderful! I sprinkled green coloured sugar on top. I was only able to squeeze 5 dozen out of the recipe, dropping from a teaspoon. They were small cookies, but good.
It was a little difficult to tell when they were done. I just had to trust the time. They did set up as they cooled. Wonderful flavor! I will make these again and again.
If you like eggnog then this recipe is for you! They were absolutely delicious, and stayed soft the way I like my cookies. These will be a new holiday tradition!
I made these cookies over the Christmas holidays and they were excellent! The spices were just right and there is nothing to change! Because these are drop cookies, nothing could be easier. This recipe will become a holiday tradition in our home. Thanks, Recipenut!
These were fabulous! I decided to add these to my Christmas cookies at the last minute this year and I'm so glad I did. Everyone who tried them really enjoyed them. Even one person who said they don't care for eggnog! I made these exactly as stated, and once they were cooled I drizzled sugar cookie icing over the tops. It worked well. Thanks so much for sharing this recipe. I'll definitely make it again in future years. :)
I love the festive feel to these cookies. They are a great addition to my Christmas cookie tray - thank you! My children love them too, so everyone gives a thumbs up rating here. Thanks for sharing this keeper.
Great, great, recipe! I'm fairly new at baking cookies, but this recipe was so easy to follow, and also tasted wonderfully. I also added a pecan on top the cookie after I sprinkled the nutmeg, gave it a great presentation. Thanks!
I have this exact recipe in my Mrs Fields Cookie Book.I just made them for the first time and they are wonderful!The only change I made was to use Vanilla Eggnog instead of the regular eggnog.The smell in the kitchen when they are baking is amazing!I will make these again for sure!
Good cookies, nice and crisp. Almost a cross between shortbread and sugar cookie. My only disappointment was that there was no distinctive eggnog flavour. The eggnog really just gave a nice consistency to the cookie, not much flavour.