This was a very tasty, hearty soup. I haven't cooked with red lentils before, and I was pleasantly surprised. I made the recipe as written, but I ended up adding 1 litre of broth, as the soup was the consistency of paste with the 2 cups called for. Not sure what could account for the difference from sherrilljoy's version, but the problem was easily rectified. The flavour was fantastic! Made for Fall PAC 2012. Thanks for posting.
This soup has the possibility of excelling to a really good soup. However it isn't quite there as written. Like the other poster I had to continue to add liquid to the soup because the lentils as they cook absorb so much of the liquid called for in the recipe. I originally added only the ingredients listed...but found it needed much more flavoring. It was much too bland for our palate. I added a bay leaf, a couple of chicken bouillion cubes, and about 1 teaspoon of Half Sharp Paprika for a little bit of heat, then simmered some more. In the end it was an excellent soup. I debated about how many stars to give. I felt since the veggies just needed some extra boosts to enhance the flavors I would give it 4 stars. (I would have liked to give it 3 1/2 stars, but since it isn't possible it deserves a 4 rather than a 3.) IMHO with the added flavor enhancers it is actually closer to a 5. Made for PAC Spring 2013.