Easy Coconut Custard Pie

Recipe by Wildflour

Simple, rich and delicious! Even better served warm with vanilla or butter pecan ice cream! (Makes it's own crust.)

Top Review by jody3444

I had another version of this and lost it. Made this recipe and my entire family raved about it. I love the flavor that the rum adds to the pie. SO far I have made 4 pies and given them to my family and they love it!

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. In mixer, (or whisk a lot), the eggs, cream, sugar, flour, butter, vanilla, rum extract and salt.
  2. Scrape bowl, and mix or whisk again til very well mixed.
  3. Add coconut, and mix/whisk in well.
  4. Pour into a 9" or 10" deep-dish greased pie plate.
  5. Bake at 350º for 50-55 minute or til set.
  6. Serve warm, room temperature or chilled.
  7. ***Thispie tends to juice over just a bit, I put it on the rack in center of oven, then on the rack below, I put a little foil just slightly bigger than the pie plate to catch the juice.
  8. Pie will sink slightly after cooling a bit.
  9. Good with vanilla or butter pecan ice cream when served slightly warm!

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a