5-star rating is for sauce #2.. it was a delicious sweet/hot flavor that complemented my egg rolls really well! I warmed it on the stove to melt down a bit and allowed it to cool before serving. Will def be making this again, it can't get any easier! I really wanted to try #1 as well, but the supermarket I stopped at didn't have pineapple jelly.. I should have gone to Publix (where shopping is a pleasure) like I usually do, they have everything. Thanks for posting your gramma's sauces, Shawn..