5 Reviews

WOW, these are truly awesome and you are my hero! :) I spent a year living in Ireland when I was in school and fell in love with McVities Digestives. However being from Germany, I cannot get them easily back home. Ive been wanting to duplicate them, but never found the perfect recipe until now. Yours truly is it! The biscuits came out nearly PERFECT! My only mistake was to roll out the dough too thick, so that my digestives ended up a bit on the poofy side. Next time Ill fix that, though. Also I think adding a tiny bit of salt to the dough would make them even better.
As I didnt have it on hand, I left out the shortening and I also used milk instead of half and half.
THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH for sharing this recipe with us, SerenaWeber!

4 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Lalaloula July 04, 2011

Thank goodness for someone who has read the McVities packet.<br/>McVities Digestives are nothing like Graham Cookies !!<br/>This recipe is wonderful. I added 1/2 Teaspoon of salt and a also found them a bit too sweet<br/>The dough is very 'gloopy' and difficult to manage.<br/>But the taste is wonderful.<br/>Congratulations.

3 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
tworg July 19, 2013

I haven't tried McVities, but I love these cookies. They're light, crisp, not too sweet, and I can pretend they're healthy because they're full of fiber. I left out the cream of tartar, because all it does is turn the baking soda into baking powder, and there's enough leavening in the recipe without. I also used one egg instead of half-and-half as the binder. One large egg is approximately 3 Tbsp. of liquid, so the ratio was unchanged. The dough was very sticky, and to make it manageable I ended up adding a lot more flour. Next time I'll refrigerate the dough before rolling so the grains have time to soak up the liquids. With the added flour, I had enough dough for two dozen 3" cookies. They're fine by themselves, but even better with chocolate (obviously!). One melted 1/2 cup of semi-sweet chocolate chips was just about the perfect amount to cover the backs.

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Tamara July 07, 2015

This recipe looks great! Can't wait to try them. Has anyone made them with Caramel? Any suggestions?

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Emanuelswife September 15, 2014

My husband was born and raised in Rhyl, Wales UK -- We have spent quite a bit of money on McVities at Cost Plus World Market over the years. :) I made a batch of Bara Brith (delicious fruit tea bread, Welsh) this morning and thought, "Wonder if I can find a good digestives recipe..." My resident Welshman just declared this to be "top shelf"! I appreciated the advice to add salt -- we will lower the amount to 1/4 tsp next time, but otherwise this is a wonderful, authentic recipe! Oh, one more thing... I did this by hand as the recipe called for. I would not recommend a mixer or food processor. I think that a delicate hand, and not over-mixing provided the delicate crumb and crispiness that we all adore in a McVities digestive.

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Andy D. October 12, 2013
Digestive Biscuits