Dad's Perfect Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

Total Time
10mins
Prep 5 mins
Cook 5 mins

More about process than ingredients, Dad very carefully taught me how to make his grilled cheese sandwiches this way so that they came out perfect every time. :)

Ingredients Nutrition

  • 2 pieces good white French bread or 2 pieces sourdough bread or 2 pieces potato bread
  • 3 slices cheddar cheese (Tillamook or your favorite, but Tillamook is so darned good! Real Cheddar from England would be acc)
  • 2 tablespoons butter

Directions

  1. Cut the slices of cheddar cheese; not too thick, but not skimpy, either; cut one slice in half.
  2. Take the two slices of bread and generously butter each of them on one side.
  3. Heat up a cast iron skillet over medium heat.
  4. Get yourself the cover from a Revereware saucepan, or another cover of about the same size.
  5. Place one of the slices of bread, butter side down, in the hot skillet.
  6. Spread 2 and a half slices of cheese on the bread, then cover it butter-side-up with the other slice of bread; eat the extra, unused half of the cheese slice.
  7. Push the bread down a little with the metal spatula, then cover the whole thing up with the saucepan lid (the idea is to heat the air up underneath the lid and melt the cheese faster as you're also browning the bread).
  8. Uncover every minute and check the cooking bread color- you want it golden, not burnt (no matter what Mom says - she likes 'em black for some reason).
  9. When it's to the color you like, carefully flip the sandwich over, press down on it with the spatula to squish the bread and cheese together, and re-cover with the saucepan to continue melting the cheese.
  10. After about 3-5 minutes of slow cooking, you'll have a wonderfully golden, melty, gooey grilled cheese sandwich!
Most Helpful

5 5

Thanx for the tip about covering the sandwich to ensure that the cheese is melted. I'll do that 2nite - and I agree with your dad - no "burnt offerings" in my house!!

5 5

Thanks Julesong for the great tip. I don't have a cast iron skillet, so used a non stick pan. I had some yummy garlic cheddar cheese from Jan S (thanks Jan) & wanted to try your Dad's method. Use of the lid ensures that the centre is hot & gooey without burning the outside - yum! Thanks for sharing.

5 5

I make my grilled cheese sandwiches the same way your dad does. I have also used Mayonnaise on the bread instead of butter. It comes out less greasy and gives the sandwich a nice flavor.