I have made this twice and it turned out wonderful both times. I might suggest fresh rosemary because the dried herbs tend to get harder when cooking at 450.
This turned out amazing!! The whole family loved it!!
I used a goat roast for this recipe and used the dutch oven method -- it turned out very tasty. I think I will use the crockpot the next time though, as that method just seems easier to me. Thank you for sharing!
Good stuff! I didn't have any canned tomatoes, so mixed in a couple tablespoons of tomato paste with the beef broth instead. I used italian seasoning in place of the thyme, oregano and basil (since those are the main ingredients in the seasononing mixture). I don't think my subs would have changed the outcome of the posted recipe very much, so giving it 5 stars as-is -- super yummy dinner!
I need 10 stars for this one, Bergy. The thyme really added to the flavor--I used twice as much as indicated, since crock pot cooking depletes spices. Left out the tomatoes, but added potatoes as you directed. DELICIOUS Sunday dinner. Made for One Dish Wonders in Cooking Photos.
We really enjoy cross rib done in tomato juice. And this recipe is wonderful. For our preferences...next time I will leave out the herbs as it was almost like a spaghetti sauce flavour...not what I was looking for. But I should have known when I read the ingreds. I used my stick blender to make it more like a gravy and served it with yorkshire pudding. Thank you, Bergy for sharing this great recipe. I will be making this again.
This is a very good pot roast and it made my house smell wonderful all afternoon. My husband, however, doesn't think tomatoes belong in a pot roast. I did cut the thyme and oregano to 1/2 tsp. each and was glad that I did. I used the beef broth and the 'gravy' was very good. The veg gets very overdone but it does flavour the gravy nicely. I put the potatoes in 45 minutes before the end and they were perfect. I used small potatoes in their skins. Thanks for sharing your recipe.
Wow!! What a wonderful recipe, will certainly be making this over, & over & over again!!! A real hit with family & company!!
This was very good. This was the first time I've ever made a roast in a dutch oven. My roast was a little dry, I evidently over cooked it a little. The flavor was still very good. I strained the vege's and made gravy for the meat and mashed potatoes. Very flavorful. Thanks, Bergy!
Cooked this for my fussy family. Beef really tender. Might add carrots later next time. Its a keeper. Thank you.