- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
There were some good and not so good things about this recipe. Good - the pecan flavor is very pronounced (yummy!) and they aren't overpoweringly sweet, these taste very GOOD! Not so good - the amount of ice water listed is not nearly enough, I ended up adding almost 3T more to get the right crumb consistency and we've had some very humid weather so I don't think my flour is dry - I had to bake nearly 30 minutes to get the centers looking done and the tops to brown, but maybe they aren't supposed to look done because mine turned out very DRY which was a real disappointment considering how good they taste. Also, I was only able to shape 18 sticks about 4" long and fatter than my thumb, I just couldn't shape them any thinner without them breaking apart. I will be making these again because the taste is great but I'm going to have to play with the recipe a bit so I can get them done without a dry texture. Thank you!!
This was a great recipe with an excellent, VERY catchy flavor. The sweetness is not overpowering, just subtley addicting. But if it's not sweet enough for you, add some caramel on top--it tastes good!! I also had to add more water but the mixture will still be crumbly--this is not like a cookie dogh, just press the mixture together. I scaled this recipe down to one serving of 1 dozen and got more like 10 smallish ones. Also, I found that by putting the powdered sugar in a sifter the coat came out evenly instead of sticking in groups when you just try to throw it on. Great recipe!!
These were so easy to make, and tasted so nutty. I really like the fact that they aren't too sweet. The sweetness comes mostly from the powdered sugar coating. I did have to add some more ice water before the dough came together, but they came out just fine. Very good.