This was my first time on making potato salad. I'm so glad I picked this recipe. I made this for a graduation party, and everyone loved it. I think 2nds were had by all. The only thing I did differently was to make an extra batch of dressing. I was making for a large crowd, did recipe times 3, so I felt like it was a little dry without it. But was perfect with one extra batch of dressing. Thank You!
Excellent recipe. Several people told me it was the best potato salad they had ever eaten. I'll make this one every time.
Got very high reviews from everyone who ate it last weekend. Even my husband who does not like potato salad loved it and is volunteering me to bring it to everything. Thanks for a great recipe!
Very good! Thanks for the recipe.
Wonderful!! Wouldn't change a thing! Gets rave reviews when I make it.
Fantastic! I made it just the way you said to, and it turned out great. I took a small portion right after I finished making it, and gave it to the pickiest potato salad eater in the world: my husband. He practically licked the bowl clean. This recipe is a keeper for sure. Thanks!
Lets get this one to the top. Very good and full of flavor, for me potato salad is an okay side dish but this one can stand alone. I will be making this recipe the one to go to. Boiled potatos for about 35 min and they came out perfect. I also added more egg, I just use the same amont of eggs as potatos.
This was very good ! I left out the Bacon and the Celery seed, but it was still great Potato Salad. I will definitely make this again. Thank you for sharing your recipe.
This is awesome!!!!
I totally forgot to rate this recipe! I have made it approximately three times and each time I have not had the celery or red onion. I used yellow onion and omitted the pickle relish and sugar altogether. I also add marinated artichoke hearts and aleppo pepper! Thanks for a great potato salad recipe!