Creamsicle Milkshake

Total Time
Prep 5 mins
Cook 0 mins

This tastes just like that orange-y ice cream bar you loved when you were a kid! From The Comfort Diner Cookbook.


  1. In the cup of a milkshake mixer or the pitcher of a blender, combine the ice cream, sherbet, and orange juice.
  2. Blend for 3 minutes in a milkshake mixer or 1 to 1 1/2 minutes in a blender.
  3. The milkshake should be so thick that a straw stands up on its own in the middle of the shake.
Most Helpful

I didn't get to make this for the Winter Comfort Cafe,Jan.2010,so I saved it to my cookbooks. SO HAPPY I DID!! This is wonderful!! The entire family enjoyed it. We will have this over & over- Thanks!!

kellychris January 25, 2010

Perfect recipe for a great tasting milkshake. My DS and GS love creamsicle ice cream and this just fits the bill and is a lot healthier using the orange juice! I was honored by making this in memory of your beloved husband. Love ya friend! :)

HokiesMom April 29, 2009

Top notch recipe for a yummy treat. Brings back memories of playing outside all day in the summer with friends and eating a creamsicle at the park. Thanks for the memories! Made for Lazyme Cook-a-thon in memory of her DH.

AcadiaTwo April 23, 2009