These are delicious cookies and I love the way the top is crackled. Very easy to make. I added about 1/3 cup molasses for the 2 cups of flour and I didn't find the dough too soft. My kitchen was a bit on the cool side though, I can see that the dough might be softer in hot weather. I also added a bit extra cinnamon, since we love cinnamon. Great cookies, thanks for the recipe, Janet W.
These were very good cookies. I added a little more molasses than the recipe called for (I was emptying the bottle) and the dough still didn't turn out too sticky. I didn't have to add more flour to compensate. I might add a little more cinnamon the next time - personal preference - but otherwise I wouldn't change a thing. These cookies came out soft and warm from the oven, then became crunchy and good, but not hard, when they cooled. I'll make these again!
Should be a 10 star review, being from Alaska I was spoiled by Great Harvest Bread Co.'s Saturday batch of molasses cookies. I've been craving them and finally decided to try my hand at it, adding a third cup of molasses and slightly more ginger, also only cooking for 8min, I was able to accomplish both the flavor and texture! AMAZING!! Was going to share them, but now I'm not sure, thanks Janet!!
Very, very easy! I used 1/3c molasses and added more spice and they were lush! I made about 35 cookies with mine but they could have easily been made smaller or larger to suit. I might try and reduce the oil next time but other than that, lovely! Thanks for posting
Perfect, tasted exactly like I was looking for! I made a different recipe last year that used shortening which I didn't have any on hand so I searched for a recipe w/o and found this one. I did add an extra 1/2 tsp cinnamon and 1/4 tsp salt, also a tad bit more molasses. Cooked 8-9min I wanted them soft! Thanks! Easy didnt even use a mixer, just by hand.
Oh my! I shrunk the recipe so I wouldn't binge and I am GLAD I did because they are awesome! The only thing I changed was I added 1/2t of salt. Oh, I also did half whole wheat flour, half white. Twelve minutes later I am chowing down.... thanks I guess :O
Great cookies. Love all the flavors in them. Easy to work with and quick to do.
These cookies have become an autumn tradition in my house - have been making them for years. They are every bit as wonderful as the reviews here indicate! This recipe is from "Cookies" by Natalie Hartanov Haughton, published by HP Books. My copy is copyright 1983; it is a 160 page softcover book, and is falling apart at the seams, as I use it so often! Hope this helps those of you searching for the original source.
YUM! These cookies have a beautiful crisp outside and soft middle. They were easy to mix up and the flavor is delicious. Perfect recipe as written!
Pretty good cookie!! I made these with 1/2 whole wheat flour and couldn't tell the difference. I also rolled them in Turbinado sugar instead of regular sugar....crisp on the outside and chewy on the inside. A keeper!