- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
Very good. I used this recipe to decorate heart shaped Rice Krispie treats for Valentines day. Used as much milk as I needed for the right consistency. : )
This frosting is delicious! I did have to add quite a bit more milk than what the recipe called for. I added a little at a time until I had the right consistency. We used it for cut out sugar cookies for my sons Christmas party. I will definitely use this one again.
This frosting was delicious...but I had problems getting it to the consistency that I wanted. I added a little merengue powder to get some firmness.
super recipe!! tasted like vanilla ice cream deliciousness. i needed way more milk than it called for, but i added 1/2 tblsp at a time until it was the consistency i wanted. definitely will be using this recipe from now on!
Just made this for Valentine's cookies and love the flavor and texture. I usually have a had time getting a good consistency but this turned out great! I did add a dab more milk than called for... Thanks.
This recipe is a sure fire way to get a great frosting for much cheaper than store bought frosting. Just make sure to add additional milk/sugar/butter as you mix if the consistency is not right. Do not add additional vanilla or it'll be too strong.
My husband tasted this and told me to, "keep this one!" I didn't have unsalted butter and didn't notice anything odd or too salty by using salted. I tripled the recipe to have enough frosting to frost six dozen 2 1/2" cut-out cookies. I had about 1/2 cup of frosting left over which I froze for later use. I also doubled the vanilla and used half and half for the milk. I will be trying more SilentCricket recipes in her memory!!
Delish! We used these to frost sugar cookies for Christmas and it worked great and was tasty. Thanks for posting!
Excellent. It makes my sugar cookies so pretty. Thanks for posting.
This recipe got me started, this was my first attempt at cookie icing! I ended up using 6Tbsp butter to 2 cups of sugar, and more like 1-1.5 T of milk. I guess I prefer a little creamier, less sweet frosting. Consistency came out perfect on my sugar cookies (came out just like Lofthouse!). Thanks for the easy recipe!