Nice treat for your sweet tooth. Mine didn't set up completely either, but it still tasted good. Made for October 2010 Think Pink Tag.
Although this is quite a delicious confection, I found that it did not set properly. I followed the directions as given. Perhaps it needed to sit for longer. I was not going to waste the batch so I spread the coconut ice mixture on to milk coffee biscuits and they were great.
Very yummy! I made these for a Christmas function and part of some Christmas gifts. I think there may be a mistake with the recipe because I didn't think 1/4 cup coconut was enough for 4 3/4 cup of icing sugar, so I used 4 1/4 cups of coconut and it seem to mix together. Once I figured this out it was so easy to prepare. Everyone at the Christmas party really enjoyed these, there was none left on the plate. Thank you for posting Perfect Pixie
I was going to only give 3 stars because mine never set up. However, the taste is excellent (if a little sweet, but that's to be expected) and I discovered that it makes a fabulous dip for strawberries. So, I had to give credit for that possiblity. I will try this again in the future, maybe with a smaller size can of condensed milk.