It was okay.. It tasted like the average picnic potato salad but with onions. I'm not a big fan of the onions but it was a pretty nice recipe.
I have made this several times for gatherings and it is always a hit! Thanks for sharing!
I took this to a family gathering and got great comments from many people.Thank you so much.
This is the best potato salad! My family asked me to make it again before the first batch was even gone!
Very Good, I even tried baking the potatoes. Turned out great for the fourth of July 2010
This was great, I did add some fresh dill to it just before serving.
you can also use cauliflower its less carbs any really can't tell the difference that much.
This was really good! I left out the onions and used fat-free mayonnaise. Because of leaving out the onions and using the fat-free mayo, I will add a little bit more mustard for more zest next time.
Just finished making this, added some freshly picked dill and oregano to the mix and it was amazing! It tasted so good I didn't even want to put this away to chill! I cannot wait to have this for lunch and maybe even dinner!
I made this as written, and it was disgustingly sweet. I tried to fix it, but it was still waaaaayyyy too sweet. Why would you put sugar in potato salad in the first place?? I chucked the first batch of dressing and made it again sans sugar, and it was meh. Since it has such high ratings, I guess people like super sweet potato salad. I don't. I won't be making it again.