4 Reviews

Great cookie!!! I can see all kinds of different toppings for the center. I made the recipe as written, chosing no nuts and topping the filling with mini chips. I had no problems handling the dough, even though I didn't first refrigerate it. Thanks for sharing the recipe. Made for PRMR tag game.

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
diner524 December 20, 2010

I am not going to assign stars as I think I made a mistake in preparing these cookies. Chalking it up to the heat. My dough was very soft and tender even after chilling for 2 hours. Rolled in the egg white and chopped walnuts as presented and ended with a decidedly different cookie, entirely flat and wafer-like with a nutty ring on the outside. Certainly no place to leave my thumbprint behind. My guess is that I mis measured the flour and plan to adjust with my remaining cookie dough. All that said, the cookies were delicious; rich in deep chocolate they were more like a brownie in cookie form. Certainly a taste I think will carry in the proper preparation. Update: I added additional flour and prepared the remaining dough, but think I added a wee too much. Sigh! The cookies were delicious and had a light cherry note with the chocolate. They were snapped up quickly and enjoyed by my co-workers immensely. If two consecutive mistakes can result in great cookies, you know the proper recipe has to be great.

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
justcallmetoni August 15, 2008

I love this chocolate version of thumbprints. They worked out perfectly for me and look great on my cookie trays. My guests have loved them and ask for the recipe. Thanks for sharing!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Lainey6605 December 18, 2007

I split the dough and rolled only half in peanuts (rather than walnuts) and they look so pretty. The other half, I did not roll in anything and they spread out alot so they weren't as pretty. Put a mint kiss in those and tinted the icing/filling green. Next time, I would add a bit more flour if not rolling in nuts just to make them spread out less. Both versions taste very good though. Thanks for posting.

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
mums the word December 13, 2007
Chocolate Thumbprints