5 Reviews

Simple, fast PERFECTION!

1 person found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
ms.susan February 25, 2009

Excellent! I did do some reading to sort of supplement all of the great info in this recipe just because it was my first attempt at steaks in my cast iron pan. We had New York strip steaks, and I used canola oil (wasn't sure if the extra virgin olive oil I had would be a bad idea due to smoke point). Instead of 3 minutes each side, I went with 2 minutes each, then a pat of butter before the oven. I used a digital meat thermometer to be certain (aimed for 125 degrees since it still cooks up to 130 degrees while sitting in foil), and that part was a bit less than 5 minutes with our cuts. Yes, the whole place was super smoky, but it was more than worth it. For the sauce, I only had Champagne on hand (day after New Year's Eve and all...), so I used it to deglaze and added some Dijon mustard, crushed garlic cloves and chopped fresh basil, and it also made a nice sauce. Even if I did some things slightly different, your recipe gave clueless about cast iron cookware me the awesome outline from which to create the best at home steak either of us have ever had, so all the glory and all the stars to you for sharing.

1 person found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Maggie, Cooking January 02, 2008

Delicious! My steaks were thick, and cooked as directed, the outside was blackened and the inside medium-well which was just right. Just something to watch if you prefer a rare steak. Only problem I had was the billowing smoke that results from cooking a steak in a hot cast iron skillet. A few hours later, it's still a bit foggy in here, but the results were well worth the smoke! While the suggested sauce sounds fantastic, I made Blue Cheese-Shallot Butter #67397 and enjoyed the combination very much. Thanks for wonderful directions and a great steak!

1 person found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
LonghornMama June 20, 2006

The flavor was AWESOME! However, the times are completely off. My steaks were about 7/8" thick. I only did them 2 min/side and 3 min in the oven and still steak was almost well done NOT medium rare. I did the sauce exactly as recipe said, and it was fantastic! I will do this again but only 1 min/side and 2 min in oven.

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Langeo April 24, 2015

Wonderful, I used flat iron steaks and added small sliced portobello mushrooms which I suateed separately and added to the sauce. Thanks, this is a keeper

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
ejriii February 25, 2007
Cast Iron Steak