7 Reviews

I've been making these for years but couldn't quite get them right - then I used this recipe and they turned out perfect! I also used a thin confectioners sugar-milk-mint glaze and dusted them with crushed candy canes :-) A really great recipe.

1 person found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Chef Maggie Mae December 18, 2005

These are a very festive addition to a Christmas cookie tray, but the taste didn't appeal to me. As fussy as they were to prepare, I guess I hoped they would be wonderful. But my grand kids loved them! I added a couple tablespoons of additional flour and the chilled dough was easy to work. I also followed another reviewer's idea and glazed the warm cookies and then sprinkled with crushed Starlite peppermint. Following the 1/2 tsp. portioning and the 3" length, this recipe.yielded 10 dozen nice 2 or 3 bite cookies. Thanks for posting this one!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Lise in Indiana December 13, 2015

Although time consuming, these were wonderful! Took to a cookie exchange and they were a big hit! I did deviate from the directions a little, I didn't add the extracts until AFTER everything was mixed and then once I had my dough and it was split into 2 colors I added the mint to only one color and the vanilla to the other. My kids like mint but this way it was not overbearing the cookie. Some people said just right others said could use a little more(and I doubled the receipe but not the extract). Once I had my system down I was cranking out cookies like a well oiled machine! Thanks, great receipe!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
bcg.madden December 08, 2008

I have made these for Christmas one year using a recipe very similar to this one. Of course the cookies tasted great, but they were a little tedious to make, and they were also too delicate to put into cookie baskets. The idea is great, though, and if you are planning on serving them on a platter, or you don't mind if they get a little broken up, these cookies are very good. :)

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
MizEmerilLagasse July 25, 2007

These are a classic that I have made many times at Christmas. I like to separate the dough and then leave one ball white and add almond extract instead of vanilla and then I make the other half red and add the peppermint extract. These always turn out well. You can make them very small or large...as long as all the cookies on the tray are the same size, they turn out great...pull out as soon as the bottem edges have a hint of brown...but tops should not be brown at all. The only downside to this cookie is that they are difficult to store without breaking. I will continue to make these for the kids each year. Thanks for sharing the recipe!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
DogAndCatDoc January 09, 2007

These cookies were very good. They came out a little bread-like, but were still very tasty. The cane twist shape is very cute and festive. The mint is very mild but adds something different to a regular Christmas sugar cookie. The dough is very workable and easy to roll. Overall a very easy cookie to make that looks and tastes great too!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
*principessa* December 28, 2006

Very good and pretty cookie but it should be noted that the dough is VERY sticky even after chilling for 3 hours so I rolled them in a LITTLE bit a flour then twisted them together because other wise I couldn't form them. Took about 45 minutes just to form them. Baked for 11 minutes and made exactly 6 doz. Good recipe tho, thanks for posting!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
anme November 24, 2006
Candy Cane Cookies