Butterfinger Dessert

Total Time
Prep 45 mins
Cook 0 mins

This is a dessert that will not last long.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Crust: Mix together--candy bars, saltines, graham crackers sugar and butter.
  2. Press into a 9x13 pan.
  3. Save 1 cup of this mixture.
  4. Filling: Beat pudding and milk together until a thick cream.
  5. Add ice cream and beat until smooth.
  6. Pour over crust and level.
  7. Cover with whipped topping.
  8. Sprinkle remaining crumbs over top.
  9. Refrigerate.


Most Helpful

I have been looking for a recipe with butterfingers and vanilla ice cream. This recipe plus the other ratings helped me create mine. My boyfriend loves butterfinger concretes, but he always complains because they don't actually mix butterfinger into the ice cream. I omitted the sugar, only used 2 vanilla pudding packages, and 1 quart of ice cream. Crust: I omitted the butterfinger in the crust as well. I put the ice cream, pudding, milk, and 3-4 small butterfinger bars (crushed) in a bowl, and mixed till it was smooth. I poured the mixture over the crust, then put in the freezer for 30 minutes to an hour. Once the mixture was firm enough I sprinkled crushed butterfinger (2 small bars) on top, then covered with cool whip. Then I sprinkled the top with 2 more small crushed butterfingers. It was delicious. I used less pudding, because I wanted it to taste more like ice cream than pudding. Thank you for the receipe!!!

kacielynne22 October 09, 2009

This is really good. I think it would be better with chocolate pudding and chocolate ice cream and frozen instead of refrigerated. Also, I think I would use less pudding and more ice cream because as is, it tastes just like pudding. Thanks for sharing.

Lucky Clover February 18, 2008

I have not tried this recipe. My copy is slightly different. It calls for no sugar, 1/2 cup saltine crackers, 1 1/2 cup graham cracker, 3 vanilla puddings, 1 quart ice cream, 8oz cool whip. The rest is the same. My copy says it serves 10 to 12. Thanks for posting. Christine (internetnut)

internetnut March 12, 2007

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a