I made this bread exactly as stated. I kept it in the machine for the whole process, not taking the dough out, forming it into a loaf and then placing it in the oven (why do some people do that?!) ... It was VERY good and came out in a perfectly shaped loaf ... I just want to add that my bread machine has Medium, Large and X-Large settings. I used the Large setting based on the amount of flour stated in the recipe. I hope some of you find this useful. Thanks for the recipe andypandy!
Awesome recipe. Somehow my bread didn't rise in the middle - but it was a beautiful texture - had excellent flavor and my husband & I both loved it. Maybe I made a mistake. But even if it turns out exactly the same way - we would definitely make it again. I also subsituted 2 cups whole wheat pastry flour and 1/2 cup of spelt flour instead of regular whole wheat and bread flour.
Excellent! Used ingredients exactly as recipe indicated. I was afraid it wasn't rising adequately in the so I removed it to a pan for the second rise. It turned out a big beautiful loaf with wonderful texture and flavor. I will definitely make this again! Thanks for posting.
Perfect recipe! I often don't care for the way bread turns out in a bread machine but this bread had the perfect texture. I followd it exactly as written.
andypandy, My first attempt at making Pumpernickel bread but not my last now that I have found this wonderful recipe. No more store purchased loaves for me. Served it with spinach dip. I will have this recipe close at hand. Excellent!
What a delicious recipe! I made rolls out of the dough and my family just loved them! Used potato water instead of plain water and added wheat gluten because I used white whole wheat flour in place of bread flour...the rolls were so soft and moist! Wonderful with my homemade soup! Thanks for posting!
Love this recipe! Made it in my bread machine and it turned out great. Thanks!
Have to rate this one right now - so I can find it in a hurry! Snow and weather warnings have cancelled a city shop - off to make a loaf to assure pumpernickel for our Christmas Eve appetizer - just wouldn't be Christmas without that hollowed out loaf filled with that Knoor recipe which has been tradition at our house 'like forever' This is a wonderful pumpernickel bread which the family loved and the teenager proclaimed his favoraite. Only had two tablespoons of cocoa on hand at the last baking, we found it just right for our tastes. Added to my Bread Favorites Cookbook. Thank you for posting a recipe for pumpernickel that we will be making again and again.
Great pumpernickel bread. I made ham and swiss cheese sandwiches and they were great.
I just made this bread and it turned out great. This will definitely be my pumpernickel bread recipe.