- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
Wonderful potato salad. I cut the recipe in half and didn't add the hard boiled eggs (family preference) then followed as written, using the Miracle Whip. This made plenty more than enough to feed 3 people. I put the pickles in my mini chopper and pulsed it a couple of times. Thanks for sharing Nimz. Made for ABC tag.
I had a hard time feeding 6 people using only 4 c. potatoes, so I doubled the recipe. I left out the sweet pickles and used all dill instead. I used mayo. Love the addition of the celery seed in the recipe. I added lots of fresh cracked pepper. I found it to be a tad too salty, as I cooked the potatoes in salt, plus the salt from the pickles. Next time I will cut down. All in all a good basic salad that will be repeated with a few changes. Thanks for sharing Nimz!
Great recipe! Easy to make. A little salty but I added a little sweet gherkin juice to the dressing and it balanced the salt out just fine. My family loved this salad and asked me to make this our "family favorite".
This is a great potato salad. We loved the mixture of the sweet and dill pickles in this. Thanks for posting.
Great Potato Salad ~Nimz~, I didnt have any dill pickle, so I used a little more gherkin, but it went down a treat here! Very creamy and the flavours were fantastic together. DS who loves his potato salad and who doesn't like mustard gave it a thumbs up! He commented on how nice it was with mustard! Great easy and very tasty recipe. Will be keeping this one! Thanks ~Nimz~
LOVED this. Made it for my husband and father-in-law...got raves! A keeper.
great potato salad
Great potato salad Nimz! I love celery seed so I did add a little more and used Miracle Whip. Doubled the recipe using Idaho potatoes and this was a hit with my whole family. For a garnish I sprinkled with paprika and added some sliced hard boiled egg on top.
I second what a lot of other reviewers have said. When I eat potato salad, I do not want to have my tastebuds challenged. Having said that, this is one GREAT potato salad! Just the right amounts of everything I like and no more. The dressing was just enough to bind the salad together and not make a gloppy mess. A repeat for us.