Best Ever - Make Ahead Potatoes

Total Time
1hr 45mins
Prep 15 mins
Cook 1 hr 30 mins

If you have looked at any of my other recipes, you will see I am a lover of creating copycat recipes!!! This one is a tribute to Moxie's Stuffed Baked Potato. It is one of the many most requested by dinner guests in our home!!!

Ingredients Nutrition

  • 4 potatoes (For Serving)
  • 2-3 potatoes (Extra Boiled and mashed if needed (boxed work too)
  • 236.59 ml bacon bits (NOT simulated)
  • 14.79 ml garlic
  • 59.14 ml butter (more or less depending on your taste)
  • 14.79-29.58 ml milk
  • 236.59 ml shredded cheese, of your choice
  • 118.32 ml chives (to garnish) or 118.32 ml green onions (to garnish)


  1. Slice 4 Potatos in half length ways and wrap in foil (2 together making a whole potato) Bake for 1 hour at 400-425 Or until baked through.
  2. Boil the remaining potatos, or prepare a box of instant mashed potatos set aside.
  3. Remove the baked Potatos from the oven, and scoop out middle leaving enough potato that the skin wont collapse.
  4. Place the scooped out portion and the prepared mashed potatos in a bowl, with the butter, garlic, milk and cheese mix well then add bacon bits and continue mixing.
  5. At this point you may spoon them into the potato shell, or fill a large piping bag wiht large star tip and pipe it in as I do.
  6. Once you have filled them, pop them in the oven at 200 or so to keep warm, or make earlier in the day and bake at about 350 for about half an hour.
  7. Garnish with green onion (I peel mine with a veggie peeler to make curly strips) or Chives.


Most Helpful

These are great potatoes. I made these for a dinner party along with NY strip steaks and stuffed mushrooms. Everyone raved over the potatoes. Thanks!

cervantesbrandi April 07, 2009

These were pretty good! After baking and filling the shells back up, I stuck them under the broiler for a few minutes. I used a small amount of instant potatoes for filler and added the green onions to the mix. Next time I will add some sour cream just because I love it! Thanks ChickNpie! Made for PAC Spring 2009.

PrimQuilter April 06, 2009

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a