Beef Stroganoff in the Mellinkoff Manner

Total Time
Prep 0 mins
Cook 40 mins

My very favorite stroganoff. The original recipe came from Ruth Mellinkoff's "The Uncommon Cook Book". The original recipe uses beef tenderloin, but to economize I use NY steak or beef sirloin (choice cut) .

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Saute mushrooms and onion in the 3 T butter and add salt and pepper. Cook 3 minutes and add the 1/2 C Sherry wine and stir. Slowly mix in the sour cream using a wire whisk and add the paprika, and lemon juice. Set aside.
  2. In a small saucepan, melt the 2 T butter with 2 T flour. Add the beef stock over low heat and stir until sauce is very thick. Add this into the sour cream mixture.
  3. Cut the meat into slices 2" by 1/4" and then season with some salt and pepper. Sear them quickly in the 1 T oil until browned on both sides and remove from the pan. Don't do too many slices at a time (it won't sizzle). Continue with remaining meat slices and remove from pan. Drain fat from the skillet and add 1/4 C sherry wine to the pan and deglaze.
  4. Stir in tomato paste, sour cream mixture, and meat. Taste and add more salt, lemon juice or paprika as needed.
  5. Serve over egg noodles.


Most Helpful

A lovely and delicious stroganoff! I added just a touch of cayenne and a teaspoon of dijon. Just delightful. I had mine over a baked potato and the rest of the family had theirs over noodles. Thanks for posting!

pattikay in L.A. June 16, 2008

Myself and my hubby thought this was wonderful it was very easy to make, which I always love. There was a wonderful aroma, that even drew my hubby from the office to ask what was for dinner, as it smelt so good. I made the recipe as stated except I did add a couple of garlic cloves, I do love my garlic. I may even try adding some mustard next time I make this. I have never made beef stroganoff before so do not know how this compares to an authentic recipe, for me I loved it. I figure when you find something you like why keep trying other recipes that may only disapoint. This will definitely become a regular at our house, thanks for sharing.

The Flying Chef January 27, 2008

This is the best tasting stroganoff I've ever had.. I've never used sherry or lemon juice in it before, but they definitely belong there! I think this will be the only stroganoff recipe I'll ever use now, thanks for posting it!

steve in FL December 16, 2007

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a