1 Review

I'm so sorry, I wanted to love this recipe, but I think it needs some major tweaking on the ingredient amounts. I was only able to justify three stars because the fixes to make this a great recipe are very simple, and don't require using any additional ingredients. I chose this recipe because I love apples and oatmeal, but I didn't look closely at the amounts of sugar and vanilla until I was in the middle of making this. I knew that 2 1/2 cups of sugars was way too much right off the bat (that would be too much even if I wasn't adding presweetened apple pie filling too), so I only added one cup of the brown sugar and no white sugar. I have an insane sweet tooth, so it's rare that anything is too sweet for me, but this definitely was (even with the reduced amount of sugar). I also found the amount of vanilla as written to be much too overpowering. I was tasting vanilla extract instead of appley oatmeal with the essence of vanilla. I definitely want to try this again, but next time I will only add 1 tsp of vanilla and 1/4 cup of brown sugar. I think I would love this with different amounts of sugar and vanilla, but as written, it just doesn't work for me. No disrespect to the chef, but I think that a lot of people who might like trying this type of recipe are going to pass this one over because of the amount of sugar in it. Thanks for posting, though. Made for PAC Fall 08

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Muffin Goddess October 03, 2008
Apple Pie Oatmeal