Amish Style Lemonade

Total Time
15 mins
0 mins

From the Inquirer Magazine of the Philadelphia Inquirer, August 1998. Unwaxed lemons would be ideal for this if you can find them.

Skip to Next Recipe




  1. Cut lemons in half lengthwise and slice thinly, as if for garnish.
  2. Mash them with the sugar and salt in a large, deep bowl or crock with an old-fashioned potato masher or heavy wooden spoon until the slices give up their juice, the sugar is dissolved and the juice is syrupy, about 5 minutes.
  3. Pour about half the lemon slices into a sieve over a bowl or pot, pressing the solids to release as much liquid as possible.
  4. Discard the solids and transfer the liquid to a serving pitcher.
  5. Repeat the process with the remaining lemons.
  6. Stir in the water until blended.
  7. Add ice cubes or chill, stirring just before serving over ice.
Most Helpful

5 5

This lemonade is perfect. Just the right balance of tart and sweet. I will never buy pre-made lemonade or lemonade concentrate again.

5 5

This is wonderful...indeed real lemonade... I LOVE lemonade. This was tart, tangy and sweet and nice and lemony. I cut it down to make a one person serving it was incredible. I will be making this often...thank you so much for sharing CulinaryQueen.

5 5

OUTSTANDING!!! I had been looking for a recipe for "real" lemonade to serve for a crowd and this one did the trick. I tripled the recipe and it was perfect. Just the right amount of sugar made this not too sweet and just right for our gathering. Thanks CQ!!