2 Reviews

This was really good and made me long for fall to finally arrive. I made it according to directions but I had way more than what would fit one pre-made pie crust. I'm pretty sure I could of gotten 3 pies out of it. The rest I re-froze and we enjoyed at a pumpkin flavored ice cream! Thanks..I'll be making this one again for sure since it's so darn easy!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
RHIANNA T. September 08, 2007

For many years my mother made this for the family at Thanksgiving. It is very rich, quite tasty, and fulfills the pumpkin taste during anytime of the year. You can use any vanilla ice cream, but set it out on the counter at least 15 minutes prior to incorporation into the other ingredients. The "cheap" brands work just as well as the expensive ones, as you covering up the vanilla taste with the spices. A suggestion in making this is to put it in a square or rectangular pan. It makes it so easy to cut into squares and serve.

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Lutie August 11, 2007
Amish Pie