Amish Pie

READY IN: 1hr 5mins
Recipe by Nyteglori

From an old handwritten card. This recipe originally called for fresh ice cream straight out of the ice cream churn. I took this to be at that time when the ice cream is still soft before you set it in the freezer to harden. Anyway if you want to follow the recipe as written substitute homemade ice cream in here and use it straight from the churn. Cooking time is freezing time.

Top Review by bmxmama

This was really good and made me long for fall to finally arrive. I made it according to directions but I had way more than what would fit one pre-made pie crust. I'm pretty sure I could of gotten 3 pies out of it. The rest I re-froze and we enjoyed at a pumpkin flavored ice cream! Thanks..I'll be making this one again for sure since it's so darn easy!

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Prepare graham cracker crust according to directions.
  2. Mix spices and orange juice with the pumpkin and fold into the softened ice cream.
  3. Pour into crust and freeze until firm.

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a