I just made this for a super bowl party and it's amazing. Tastes almost like the macaroni salad the Amish make
Quite tasty as-is, but I made a few changes the next time I made it which IMHO made it more tasty: Sub the sugar for about 3tbs of honey, Sub white vinegar for cider vinegar, Add 1/2 tbs celery seed, and 1/tbs dill (dried), Used dijon mustard (Was not sure if it called for yellow, but I prefer the dijon!) , and smoked paprika rather than regular. SOOO good!
WOW!!! I would give this recipe more stars if I could. This recipe is the best macaroni salad I've ever made. It's always a hit at home or whenever I take it to a covered dish venue.
I made this for our New Year's Day Open House. Everyone loved it. My husband doesn't like all macaroni salads; not too much vinegar, not too sweet. He loved this one. One comment. Since this was my first time making a macaroni salad, I want wasn't sure about how much liquid it had in it right after I made it but after sitting overnight it was perfect.
This was a big hit at our house! Unfortunately, I forgot we were out eggs, but it was great, just the same...will do the eggs next time. THANKS for sharing!!!
This is a wonderful version of that Pennsylvania Dutch Country classic. I made it for a rehearsal dinner with gluten free elbow noodles. Being GF, I haven't had Amish Macaroni Salad for at least a couple years now. It was wonderful having a great recipe to make myself with gluten free pasta so I could enjoy it again after so long! Everyone enjoyed it!
Keeper! I was searching for a recipe as close to my mother in law's as I could get (mayo, vinegar, mustard, sugar, egg, celery, onion). Based on the recipe and reviews, I decided this was the one to try. At first, I was hesitant to add all sugar but followed the recipe exactly and I am so happy I did! Family LOVED it, including kids and an adult Bona Fide mayonnaise hater! Thank you Charmed!
This has an amazing, sweet dressing. I quite liked it. I added onion & green peppers because that's what I had at home. It would be great with almost any veggie you wanted to add. Thanks for sharing your recipe.
This was very good. The dressing reminds me of Marzetti's Slaw Dressing which I love. I never tried a sweet dressing on a cold macaroni salad before but was quite pleasantly surprised. I'll make this salad at our next get to-gather.
Wonderful recipe! I have made it to take to a couple of picnics this summer and everyone has loved it.