
Hi, MrJd, and welcome to the Beverage Forum!
I think that rums are a matter of taste, to those who care for it. I, personally, have always found Bacardi to be a reliable product, from light (silver) to dark and including 151. If you want to elevate the mai-tai, I'd suggest you use Cointreau or Grand Marnier, in place of the triple sec. They are both orange flavored and suitable replacements for the triple sec.
If you'd like to try different rums, I'd suggest you purchase some of the small (airplane) bottles, to judge their taste. That way, you don't buy a bottle that you end up not liking!
I'm not sure if you searched our database, but there are 47 Mai-Tai recipes,
HERE! You are welcome to mix/taste your way through them! Reviews (constructive, of course) are always welcome, as are photos, if you are so inclined!
Here is one that I made last summer:
The Best Mai Tai
It was simple and delicious!
Good luck in your mai-tai travels!
Alli
